Peer review me

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o9bmYTxEWFTDEoeGf/peer-review-me

I wrote an article that I hoped to post on the main page, but then I got stage fright and was afraid to even put it here. So I guess I’m just going to show it to whichever of you is willing to review it privately.

Any takers? Qualifications: must be a fan of Z-movies.

Comment

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o9bmYTxEWFTDEoeGf/peer-review-me?commentId=bhRJmHTgJReL9oeA7

I’m willing but probably neither necessary nor sufficient to assuage your concerns, though I can state with certainty that I will tell you to post it in the Discussion section after reading it.

Comment

  • id
    PJaYvjJQnSdrE3sbP
  • authors
    Normal_Anomaly
  • score
    5
  • omega_karma
  • votes
    3
  • date_published
    2011-01-15T02:50
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o9bmYTxEWFTDEoeGf/peer-review-me?commentId=PJaYvjJQnSdrE3sbP

Yeah; post it in the discussion anyway.

Comment

  • id
    tZ5rai4AzpW8m97oL
  • authors
    Kaj_Sotala
  • score
    2
  • omega_karma
  • votes
    1
  • date_published
    2011-01-15T10:51

Agreed.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o9bmYTxEWFTDEoeGf/peer-review-me?commentId=Pysh26yMct2i7D3fj

You can PM it to me. I’m not a fan of Z-movies, but pretty good at parsing arguments.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o9bmYTxEWFTDEoeGf/peer-review-me?commentId=gWBtEcnHrmKM52e9L

Sure, feel free to message it to me.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o9bmYTxEWFTDEoeGf/peer-review-me?commentId=xYJE2hq4QEJdqAb3p

I like this idea; unfortunately, I don’t like Z-movies.