2021 Darwin Game—Tundra

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra

Contents

Carrion Leaves Grass Seeds Detritus Coconuts Algae Lichen

1 1 1 1 1 0 0 300

An organism must expend 20% of its energy just to survive. A herbivore foraging for lichen cannot have a size greater than 5 or else it will expend more energy in metabolism than it is possible to acquire from eating Lichen.

All organisms have base size 0.1. The cold adaptation (+2) plus the Lichen digestive tract (+1) costs a total of +3 size. A Tundra herbivore has a minimum size of 3.1. A herbivore with size 5.1 is untenable since it expends more energy (1.02) than is possible to obtain from Lichen (1.00).

Players submitted 39 species native to the Tundra. Only 4 of them were viable herbivores: Micropas, Arctic Slug, Northern Nibbler and "lichen" (not to be confused with the foragable "Lichen"). (Multicore’s Arctic Fox was a carnivore.)

These species could support little in the way of weapons, armor and speed. They were defenseless. In the first 8 turns, all four of our viable foragers are eaten to extinction.

Goes Extinct in Generation Species

5 Pristol

7 Micropas

7 Arctic Slug

8 Northern Nibbler

8 lichen

After the viable herbivores were eliminated, total ecological collapse was inevitable.

Goes Extinct in Generation Species

9 Yonge_Cold

9 Boreakeet

9 Beck’s Penguin

10 SmolFire

10 Arctic Ambusher

10 Zlorg

10 Arctic Fox

10 Orange-Krill

10 abominable_snowman

12 Antasvara

12 Unfortunately Large Cockroach

12 cg-mouse

13 Porostozer Malutki

13 1994 Mazda RX7

14 Raburetta

14 Pittsburgh-Penguins

15 Louse-lion

15 Wolverine

16 Jtp

16 Wolves

17 Seals

19 Direwolf

24 Tsc

27 Tundrus Rex

29 Frankenstein

32 Broken Fetters

34 Alaskans

37 Dragon

37 Porostozer Mamuci

39 Rocks

41 Duckofants

43 White-Whales

50 tp511

52 Frostwing Snipper

The Frostwing Snipper

An honorable mention goes to Nem’s Frostwing Snipper, a Speed 10 species that could digest both Lichen and Seeds. The maximum speed made the Frostwing Snipper immune to predation which let it survive the initial carnage. The ability to digest seeds meant that the Frostwing Snipper did consume enough energy on average to more than replace itself.

However, "on average" is not enough. The Tundra’s carrying capacity of Frostwing Snippers was too small. Random fluctuations eventually knocked the Frostwing Snipper into extinction.

Winners

None

Eratta

Simon notes that I used 50,000 instead of 1,000 for each species initial energy. Using the correct value of 1,000 doesn’t really change anything except everyone dies faster and MatIsk’s Porostozer Mamuci (which eats Carrion) takes the place of Frostwing Snipper.

Porostozer Mamuci

Venom? Yes

Weapons 1

Armor 10

Speed 10

Forager Carrion, Lichen

Temperature Adaptatations Heat, Cold

Comment

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=MzoDeczwFEWnBzphe

I am very excited that the Frostwing Snipper did so well. I hope that one of them migrated and lived a good life in the Grassland. Thanks for putting this together Isusr. It’s been a lot of fun.I wonder if the Tundra would have been more viable with more algae-eaters.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=nMK83fx6nnFSaNv5H

Hrm, according to my notes I should have submitted a LivingTrenchcoateats seedseats lichencold resistantTundra herbivore, but it is not on the list of viable herbivores. Maybe I changed my mind and submitted something else? From what I remember, an organism like that is technically viable even if it has 5.1 size by adding a point of e.g. weapons, right? If there was no competition, then one of it would eat the seeds, getting 72 entries into a 1.96% lottery, and N-1 of it would eat lichen, getting 48 entries into a 1.96% lottery, yielding an equilibrium population of 8 organisms, which might be large enough to avoid randomly fluctuating to zero. Or did I get the mechanics wrong?

Comment

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=babddowwLWKvvpHcf

According to my data, GuySrinivasan submitted SmolFire to the Tundra instead of LivingTrenchcoat. It has 2 weapons, 0 armor and 0 speed. Eats Seeds and Lichen.

Your organism is technically viable, contrary to what I wrote in the post. However, it has a very small carrying capacity (though not quite as small as the Frostwing Snipper) and its lack of both defense and predatory ability got it annihilated in the initial feeding frenzy.

Comment

Thanks for looking! I am satisfied that the smol thing was viable. :D

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=mHAkcXHoSrRgL3goj

It looks like that would have been eaten in the initial feeding frenzy?

Comment

Oh yeah definitely but I was wondering why its name didn’t appear—that I forgot I changed it, or that it actually isn’t viable, or both.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=CHZRuL73tdYDzqymo

I take it then that no one else had a cold adaptation and wandered in from elsewhere later.

Comment

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=waHEmaXaATkoWv9pE

No species did that and got established.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=vJEgWyRkjwKhs83Zb

Which random factors caused the frostwing snippers to die out? Them migrating out? Competitors or predators migrating in? Or is there some chance of not getting the seed, even if they’re the only species left? I didn’t get a good look at the source code, but I thought things were fairly deterministic once only one species was left.

Comment

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=wzBgcqWQDbL7JeNSr

IIRC every non-eaten organism gets 80% of its size, plus its nutrition, x10, in lottery tickets. Every lottery ticket has a 1/​size/​10 of being a new organism in the next generation.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=LwoYi5DhmDuHKGnft

The number of babies an organism has a random element. If it eats enough to replace itself then it will replace itself once in average but might do so zero or multiple times on average.

Migration is random too so there’s a small chance of it migrating away too. The frosting snippers mostly needn’t worry about invaders thanks to the heat.

A species will always get the seed if it is the only species left.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=bturGSQehCzMqaddM

Why is the starting population of Frostwing Snippers 3500? As far as I can see, it has Size 14.1, and I don’t know what kind of starting energy budget leads to a starting population of 3500.

(That also seems like a very large starting number, and makes me worry that even in more viable biomes there’s going to be a huge population crash.)

Comment

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fwphWpsDiBkLx8JCr/2021-darwin-game-tundra?commentId=7CLetzryacKhssqPk

The starting energy budget is 50000.

\frac{50000}{14.1}\approx3546

Comment

Yeah, that seems crazy high, with only ~300 resources to fight over. If there were a steady state, you’d expect ~300 herbivores and fewer carnivores, across all species. It’s also not the energy budget in the code I downloaded (which was 1000, and even that might be pretty high in tundra given the number of entrants and available resources).

Comment

You’re right. The code I released did have 1,000, not 50,000. This is an inconsistency between the code I released and the code I ran the game with. I apologize.

Thanks for noticing. This post tool a long time to write and basically the same thing happened (except faster) with 1,000 so I’m not going to re-write this whole post. The same goes for the Desert, which I have already written up too. I will use the correct value of 1,000 for the rest of the biomes.

Comment

Wait, are you initializing and running each biome separately? I expected all biomes to be seeded at once with the complete set of submitted organisms.

Comment

They’re all run simultaneously. I’m just writing up each biome separately.